Archive of Our Own ^beta

Recent bookmarks

1. Rec 13

   Feeling like a face in the crowd by SunshineAndaLittleFlour

   Fandoms: Critical Role (Web Series)  

   • Explicit
   • No Archive Warnings Apply
   • M/M, Multi
   • Complete Work

   17 May 2023

   Tags

   • No Archive Warnings Apply
   • Mollymauk Tealeaf/Essek Thelyss/Caleb Widogast
   • Mollymauk Tealeaf/Caleb Widogast
   • Mollymauk Tealeaf/Essek Thelyss
   • Essek Thelyss/Caleb Widogast
   • Mollymauk Tealeaf
   • Caleb Widogast
   • Essek Thelyss
   • Yasha (Critical Role)
   • Eavesdropping
   • it's yasha's turn to give caleb and essek a shovel talk
   • and molly gets to have Big Feelings about it
   • as well as Big Feelings about his wizards
   • then sex against the front door
   • Oral Sex
   • Hand Jobs
   • it's not technically public sex because they are in their own home
   • but the neighbors For Sure heard some things
   • Caleb and Molly and Essek laugh their way through sex
   • Yasha is a good friend

   Summary

   Instead, very quietly— almost too quiet for Molly to hear, Caleb said, “Are you worried about him, is something the matter?”

   Am I the matter? he didn’t ask, but Molly could hear it just the same, insecurity as familiar as Caleb’s worn leather coat.

   Yasha laughed, quiet and sure and kind. “I am less concerned by the minute. I know you well, Caleb, almost as well as I know Molly. I just wanted to be sure you were treating him right. I’ve never given a gavel talk before.”

   Caleb huffed, amusement and relief flaring to life in the kitchen. “I believe it’s called a shovel talk, and if it makes you feel any better, I’ve never received one before. I think you are supposed to threaten me with bodily harm.”

   Series

   • Part 8 of I know that you like me, And it's kinda frightening

   Language:

   English

   Words:

   4,464

   Chapters:

   1/1

   Comments:

   42

   Kudos:

   308

   Bookmarks:

   13

   Hits:

   3,137

   Bookmarked by SweetSnowyWitch

   31 Dec 2025

2. Rec 15

   A message in a bottle is all I can do, Standin' here, hopin' it gets to you by SunshineAndaLittleFlour

   Fandoms: Critical Role (Web Series)  

   • Explicit
   • No Archive Warnings Apply
   • M/M, Multi
   • Complete Work

   16 Jan 2023

   Tags

   • No Archive Warnings Apply
   • Mollymauk Tealeaf/Essek Thelyss/Caleb Widogast
   • Mollymauk Tealeaf/Caleb Widogast
   • Mollymauk Tealeaf/Essek Thelyss
   • Essek Thelyss/Caleb Widogast
   • Mollymauk Tealeaf
   • Caleb Widogast
   • Essek Thelyss
   • Blow Jobs
   • Rimming
   • Bathroom Sex
   • they actually have a really mature DTR conversation
   • and then they go fuck
   • that's it that's the story
   • this is a sort of modern fantasy au if that wasn't already clear
   • don't worry about it too much
   • there's big feelings and threesomes and that's what matters
   • They're In Love Your Honor
   • and finally actually going to talk about it
   • molly has some Big insecurities but this is my fic and I think love conquers all
   • they're also all kind of kinky and that's fun too
   • one of these days I'll actually decide what Essek and Molly's jobs are in this series
   • but until then I can be vague and just write about blowing each other in fancy restaurant bathrooms

   Summary

   He’d probably be way more comfortable blowing them one at a time in the bathroom than sitting here, pretending to know enough elvish to read the menu. He could do it, he figured, then shifted in his seat, feeling Essek’s hand gently squeeze his leg.

   Series

   • Part 6 of I know that you like me, And it's kinda frightening

   Language:

   English

   Words:

   6,072

   Chapters:

   1/1

   Comments:

   19

   Kudos:

   318

   Bookmarks:

   15

   Hits:

   4,061

   Bookmarked by SweetSnowyWitch

   31 Dec 2025

3. Rec 22

   I'm reaching for you by SunshineAndaLittleFlour

   Fandoms: Critical Role (Web Series)  

   • Mature
   • No Archive Warnings Apply
   • Multi
   • Complete Work

   12 Jan 2023

   Tags

   • No Archive Warnings Apply
   • Essek Thelyss/Caleb Widogast
   • Mollymauk Tealeaf/Caleb Widogast
   • Mollymauk Tealeaf/Essek Thelyss
   • Mollymauk Tealeaf/Essek Thelyss/Caleb Widogast
   • Mollymauk Tealeaf
   • Caleb Widogast
   • Essek Thelyss
   • the aftermath of a hookup
   • caleb and essek drive molly home and molly Experiences Feelings
   • spoilers so do essek and caleb
   • this is just an exploration of the beginning of something soft and lovely
   • disguised as a post threesome drive home
   • they're in love
   • molly has a terrible dating history and no self esteem
   • essek and caleb have a house and an unfathomable amount of love
   • both things can hold a tiefling

   Summary

   The first time Molly had sex with Caleb and Essek, he called himself an Uber right after.

   Series

   • Part 5 of I know that you like me, And it's kinda frightening

   Language:

   English

   Words:

   1,534

   Chapters:

   1/1

   Comments:

   36

   Kudos:

   394

   Bookmarks:

   22

   Hits:

   3,325

   Bookmarked by SweetSnowyWitch

   30 Dec 2025

4. Rec *

   I know that you like me, And it's kinda frightening by SunshineAndaLittleFlour

   Fandom: Critical Role (Web Series)

   • Teen And Up Audiences, Explicit, Mature
   • No Archive Warnings Apply
   • M/M, Multi, Gen
   • Series in Progress

   22 Jan 2024

   • No Archive Warnings Apply
   • Essek Thelyss/Caleb Widogast
   • Mollymauk Tealeaf/Caleb Widogast
   • Mollymauk Tealeaf/Essek Thelyss/Caleb Widogast
   • Mollymauk Tealeaf/Essek Thelyss
   • Fjord & Mollymauk Tealeaf
   • Caduceus Clay & Fjord
   • Caduceus Clay & Mollymauk Tealeaf
   • Mollymauk Tealeaf
   • Caleb Widogast
   • Essek Thelyss
   • Fjord (Critical Role)
   • Caduceus Clay
   • Yasha (Critical Role)
   • Jester Lavorre
   • this is based on that one tweet
   • you know the one
   • Drunk Kissing
   • mollymauk truly does not think before he acts
   • and then somehow it works out for him
   • don't ask what kind of au this is I don't even know
   • they have cellphones but otherwise it's all whatever
   • fantasy cellphones? idk magic is weird and I just want the purple boys to kiss
   • is this my first critical role fanfic? sure it
   • will it be the last? who's to say
   • pre-slash I think is the technical term for something like this
   • caleb and essek established relationship
   • and then molly comes in on rollerskates like
   • I am also part of this relationship thanks
   • and they're all into it
   • This is just straight up porn
   • like we've got some oral sex
   • some anal sex
   • some fingering
   • Fingers In Mouths
   • you know the drill
   • it's sleepy morning sex
   • and we're in love sex
   • and also kinda of dirty threesome sex
   • you know how it be
   • also I just want to say that it's really hard to track movements for three people
   • I almost had to draw a diagram
   • also two of them are purple so that added another level of difficulty
   • but I feel like I've leveled up in writing porn
   • simply because there are three people
   • and I only lost track of their hands a couple times
   • They're In Love Your Honor
   • I said I would write a spicy sequel and I did
   • xoxo
   • also I swear this is a modern au
   • they just conveniently don't do anything but fuck and talk about curtains
   • neither of which would indicate it's a modern setting
   • Anal Sex
   • Anal Fingering
   • the appropriate use of snow days
   • Making Out
   • I don't have much to tag here
   • I guess we can establish this is a university AU of sorts
   • mostly in that Caleb and Essek are professors
   • and Molly is a performer of some sort
   • and they're all fucking
   • and also all in love
   • it's another threesome fic
   • and this time I didn't lose track of anybody's hands
   • my confidence has never been higher
   • also I don't think I could handle this becoming a whole other brunch is series
   • so don't get too excited
   • but it is fun writing porn again ngl
   • Biting
   • Just a lil bit of blood
   • from the biting
   • this is jut real toothy sex
   • molly and essek have things to say about teeth and how sexy they are
   • esp when they're lil fangs
   • the barest amount of scratching
   • sorry I was more focused on the biting
   • molly and essek and caleb are in love and also talk about things and fuck
   • That's it
   • that's the series
   • Modern AU
   • I swear it is
   • they use cell phones sometimes just not regularly enough for me to say it every time
   • Minor Fjord/Jester Lavorre
   • they're mentioned but not actually in the fic
   • the aftermath of a hookup
   • caleb and essek drive molly home and molly Experiences Feelings
   • spoilers so do essek and caleb
   • this is just an exploration of the beginning of something soft and lovely
   • disguised as a post threesome drive home
   • they're in love
   • molly has a terrible dating history and no self esteem
   • essek and caleb have a house and an unfathomable amount of love
   • both things can hold a tiefling
   • Blow Jobs
   • Rimming
   • Bathroom Sex
   • they actually have a really mature DTR conversation
   • and then they go fuck
   • that's it that's the story
   • this is a sort of modern fantasy au if that wasn't already clear
   • don't worry about it too much
   • there's big feelings and threesomes and that's what matters
   • and finally actually going to talk about it
   • molly has some Big insecurities but this is my fic and I think love conquers all
   • they're also all kind of kinky and that's fun too
   • one of these days I'll actually decide what Essek and Molly's jobs are in this series
   • but until then I can be vague and just write about blowing each other in fancy restaurant bathrooms
   • boys day teatime
   • listen cad and fjord and molly all go get coffee/tea together and talk about their lives
   • it's therapeutic and also the dumbest conversations you've ever heard
   • this is truly just fjord marveling at the idea of polyamory
   • and molly and cad thinking it's really funny
   • that's the plot
   • no porn this time sorry
   • I just wanted characters to interact and be weird
   • and this has been sitting in my drafts forever so
   • Eavesdropping
   • it's yasha's turn to give caleb and essek a shovel talk
   • and molly gets to have Big Feelings about it
   • as well as Big Feelings about his wizards
   • then sex against the front door
   • Oral Sex
   • Hand Jobs
   • it's not technically public sex because they are in their own home
   • but the neighbors For Sure heard some things
   • Caleb and Molly and Essek laugh their way through sex
   • Yasha is a good friend
   • this is not the horniest thing I've ever written but it sure does feel like it
   • happy new year have a threesome
   • featuring molly in lingerie
   • Lingerie
   • Panty Kink
   • as in caleb has one
   • essek is more into the bralette
   • but either way they are both Stoked that Molly's wearing it
   • Fingers in Mouth
   • molly's mouth that is
   • our boys skip out on a new years party to have kinky new years eve sex
   • Come Marking
   • Come Eating
   • essek is soooo into it you guys
   • Nipple Play
   • Nipple Piercings
   • it's been a minute since I've had to use that many sex related tags
   • Smut
   • Like so much
   • but if you've read this far into this series then you know that by now

   Words:

   32,009

   Works:

   9

   Bookmarks:

   120

   Bookmarked by SweetSnowyWitch

   30 Dec 2025

5. Rec 68

   The Cure by pastelNothing

   Fandoms: Critical Role (Web Series)  

   • Explicit
   • No Archive Warnings Apply
   • M/M
   • Complete Work

   15 Aug 2018

   Tags

   • No Archive Warnings Apply
   • Mollymauk Tealeaf/Caleb Widogast
   • Mollymauk Tealeaf
   • Caleb Widogast
   • Fjord (Critical Role)
   • Yasha (Critical Role)
   • Nott (Critical Role)
   • Jester (Critical Role)
   • Trans Male Character
   • Menstruation
   • Menstrual Sex
   • Oral Sex
   • Molly takes care of his boy.

   Summary

   Some people have very good memories; plenty of thoughtfulness and awareness to a situation. Mollymauk Tealeaf isn't one of those people. He'll do his best to try and figure out what's going on but sometimes he needs a helping hand. The tiefling does learn one thing, however. Caleb Widogast is a feast

   Language:

   English

   Words:

   9,783

   Chapters:

   1/1

   Comments:

   23

   Kudos:

   568

   Bookmarks:

   68

   Hits:

   7,054

   Bookmarked by SweetSnowyWitch

   30 Dec 2025